Previous Entry | Main | Next Entry

September 02, 2003

Irony or chutzpah?

Remember the psychiatrists who claimed back in 1964 that Goldwater was not "mentally fit" to be president. The Guardian has dug up TV psychologist Oliver James to write a very silly piece about George Bush.

The outcome of this childhood was what psychologists call an authoritarian personality. Authoritarianism was identified shortly after the second world war as part of research to discover the causes of fascism. As the name suggests, authoritarians impose the strictest possible discipline on themselves and others - the sort of regime found in today's White House, where prayers precede daily business, appointments are scheduled in five-minute blocks, women's skirts must be below the knee and Bush rises at 5.45am, invariably fitting in a 21-minute, three-mile jog before lunch.
.   .   .
However, it is certain that however much Bush may sometimes seem like a buffoon, he is also powered by massive, suppressed anger towards anyone who challenges the extreme, fanatical beliefs shared by him and a significant slice of his citizens - in surveys, half of them also agree with the statement "the Bible is the actual word of God and is to be taken literally, word for word".

Bush's deep hatred, as well as love, for both his parents explains how he became a reckless rebel with a death wish. He hated his father for putting his whole life in the shade and for emotionally blackmailing him. He hated his mother for physically and mentally badgering him to fulfil her wishes. But the hatred also explains his radical transformation into an authoritarian fundamentalist. By totally identifying with an extreme version of their strict, religion-fuelled beliefs, he jailed his rebellious self. From now on, his unconscious hatred for them was channelled into a fanatical moral crusade to rid the world of evil.

This is mostly comedy, but here is the part I really like. Back in February 2001, Henry Porter wrote a withering piece about James, in which he condemned the Sunday Telegraph for using such a fraud for an attack on Peter Mandelson.
Dr Oliver James, the television psychologist, is used to remote diagnosis. A lack of personal experience of his subject presents no obstacle to Dr James, who has delivered himself of the view that Peter Mandelson was at a "high risk of suicide attempt" because of his sacking from the cabinet. Without the slightest professional qualm, he further stated that Mandelson is likely to suffer "a terrible depression" and that there is some kind of "design fault" in him.
.   .   .
Dr James, apparently an expert on everything from paedophilia to the meaning of Princess Diana's death, is not a member of the British Psychological Society, which forbids such behaviour for two very good reasons. If Mr Mandelson was indeed a suicide risk or vulnerable to depression, nothing could be more dangerous than for a doctor to announce it in the press. But since Mandelson is suffering from strain - a natural reaction to his summary dismissal - it is extremely presumptuous of James to suggest severe, long-term instability. In other words James was either downright irresponsible, or he was wrong. Whichever way you look at it, he infringed Mr Mandelson's rights and dignity.
.   .   .
It seems extraordinary that he can get away with this behaviour which in most areas of medicine would be regarded as unethical. But there is of course no professional body to which psychologists have to belong to practice and which has statutory power to limit the profession's taste for public speculation about an individual's mental health. Curiously, it is precisely James's ignorance of Mandelson's state of mind - he is not a client - which allows him to blather on without breaking the sacred confidentiality between patient and doctor.
So who published Porter's attack on James? The Guardian. The Guardian attacks the Sunday Telegraph for using a fraud like Oliver James, and then proceeds to use the same old fraud for an attack on Bush. Is that irony or chutzpah?

Posted by sjostrom on September 02, 2003 12:32 PM




Comments:

You might be interested in a book by Sigmund Freud and William C. Bullitt, "Thomas Woodrow Wilson: A Psychological Study" (Houghton Mifflin Company, 1967).

Freud and Bullitt purport to show that Wilson immagined himself to be Jesus Christ. For example (at random as I have not opened the book in perhaps 25 years), on page 179 we have "As soon as the prospect of becoming the Prince of Peace began to fade he grew intensly nervous and unhappy, and indigestion and headaches began to harrass him."

It did not begin, nor will this sort of fraud end, with James.

Regards
Johnny Johns

Posted by: John Johns on September 3, 2003 12:19 AM [Permalink]






Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?






Personal Information
Contact me
About me
Home

disproportionate response.jpg


Blogs I Like
Day by Day

Instapundit
Best of the Web
Lileks
The Corner
Israpundit
Tal G. in Jerusalem
C-Log
Pejmanesque
Arma Virumque
Andrew Sullivan
Michelle Malkin
Virginia Postrel
David Frum
Chicago Boyz
A Small Victory
Winds of Change
David Horowitz
A Voyage to Arcturus
Political Animal (Kevin Drum)
Meryl Yourish
Atlas Shrugs
Little Green Footballs
Tim Blair
Mark Steyn
Power Line
Vodka Pundit
Radley Balko
Betsy's Page
Marriage Movement
Eve Tushnet
Samizdata
Dave Barry
Ipse Dixit
No Left Turns
Clayton Cramer
Brothers Judd
NZPundit
Front Line Voices
Right Wing News
Donald Sensing
Strategy Page
A Dog's Life
Jeff Jarvis
Man Without Qualities
Michael Totten
PrestoPundit
Mickey Kaus
Social Justice Friends
Kesher Talk
Milt Rosenberg
MaroonBlog
Crescat Sententia
Gefen
Terry Teachout
The Black Republican
Banana Republican
Israellycool
Big Pharaoh
The Joy of Knitting
Protein Wisdom
Across the Atlantic
Armed Prophet
A Constrained Vision
Hugh Hewitt
Real Clear Politics
Belmont Club
Avian Flu
Globalization Institute Blog
Harry's Place
Right Reason
Robert George

Economist Bloggers

Cold Spring Shops
Eric Rasmusen
Newmark's Door
Asymmetrical Information
The Knowledge Problem
The Sports Economist
Bruce Bartlett
Economic Principals
Marginal Revolution
Poor and Stupid
Brad DeLong
John Lott
Institutional Economics
Truck and Barter
John Quiggin
Indiawest
Transport Blog
Arnold Kling
Ben Muse
Deinonychus Antirrhopus
The Idea Shop
Cafe Hayek
Division of Labor
EclectEcon
Market Power
Becker-Posner Blog
voluntaryXchange
Canadian Econoview
Econbrowser
Johan Norberg
Tim Harford's Dear Economist
Private Sector Development Blog
Greg Mankiw
Freakonomics Blog
David Friedman
Organizations and Markets






Other Social and Political Science Bloggers

Daniel W. Drezner
Norman Geras
Mark Kleiman
Oxblog
Crooked Timber
Amitai Etzioni
The Commons
Left2Right

Lawyer Bloggers

The Volokh Conspiracy
Walter Olson's Overlawyered
Phil Carter
Howard Bashman
Stuart Buck
Southern Appeal
The Right Coast
Stephen Bainbridge
Yin Blog
Mirror of Justice
Fladen Experience
Busfilm
Ideoblog
Point of Law
Legal Theory Blog
Althouse
Chicago Law Faculty Blog
Truth on the Market
Conglomerate

Higher Schooling Blogs

Critical Mass
SCSU Scholars
Joanne Jacobs
National Association of Scholars
Number 2 Pencil
The Cranky Professor

British Bloggers

Stephen Pollard
Edge of England's Sword
Belgravia Dispatch
Natalie Solent
Biased BBC
Peter Briffa
Adam Smith Blog
Civitas
Melanie Phillips
The Black Line
The Daily Ablution

Eurobloggers

Bjørn Stærk
Fredrik Norman
Baltic Blog
Merde in France
Innocents Abroad
Davids Medienkritik

Irish Bloggers

Blog Irish
Eoin McGrath
Back Seat Drivers
Irish Eagle
Broom of Anger
Tallrite Blog
Freedom Institute
Richard Delevan



Enough Already
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
Fighting the Israel boycott
Simon Wiestenthal Center
Friends of Israel
Catholic Friends of Israel

if-07.jpg


People I Admire
Binyamin Netanyahu
Ronald Reagan
Vaclav Havel
John Wayne
Margaret Thatcher
Leon Kass
Miss Manners

Democratiya Book Advert FINAL.jpg



Site Archives
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003
July 2003
June 2003
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003
February 2003
January 2003
December 2002
November 2002
October 2002
September 2002


America (3)
Anti-American watch (7)
China (2)
Crime and punishment (8)
Economics (7)
Europundit watch (7)
Eurosilliness (5)
Family (1)
From Blogger (467)
Government (1)
International politics (5)
Irish politics (3)
Israel (5)
Jew haters (6)
News (1)
Obama Watch (35)
Politics (16)
Poverty and economic development (5)
Press watch (33)
Really important stuff (1)
Schooling and education (1)
State of the culture (7)
The higher schooling (19)
The Left (25)
The movies (4)
Totalitarian lackeys (12)
UN Watch (1)
Website Related (1)


Search the Site
Site Credits